Two people sitting at opposite ends of a sofa in a living room, one turned towards the window, the other looking at the floor

How to forgive someone who isn’t sorry: what actually blocks it

8 min read

Can you forgive someone who won’t admit they were wrong?

Yes, and it is the commonest case. Most of the offences that stay lodged in us do not end with a repair conversation: they end with a silence, a change of subject, or a version of events in which you are the problem.

Waiting for an apology has its own logic. It assumes the debt sits with the other person, and that is correct. Its flaw lies elsewhere: it makes you dependent on a gesture you do not command. Until the sentence arrives, the matter stays open, and you are the one keeping the file.

The research that measures forgiveness barely ever measures the offender’s conduct. It measures the drop in avoidance and revenge motivations in the person who was hurt (McCullough and colleagues, 1998). What gets assessed is a change in you. The other person may never find out.

Myth: without an apology, forgiveness is impossible

This idea holds because it describes a real feeling. Without acknowledgement, forgiving looks like surrender, and nobody wants to surrender. But it runs together two operations that nothing obliges you to carry out at once.

The first is relational: restoring trust, taking the bond back up, treating the debt as settled. That one does require something from the other person, and without an apology it is out of reach. The second is internal: ending the upkeep of what you carry about them. It needs no participation from them at all.

Confusing the two produces the familiar dead end, where you believe the choice is between staying angry indefinitely and absolving someone who never asked. The third option is the right one: release the charge, and keep your judgement about what happened.

What an apology changes, and what it does not

An apology is not a detail you can drop at no cost. Conciliatory gestures from the offender are among the steadiest predictors of forgiveness (Fehr, Gelfand and Nag, 2010): when they happen, it comes faster and more completely. Going without is not neutral, and there is no reason to pretend otherwise.

What they supply, precisely, is information. They say the other person saw the harm, that they may not repeat it, and that you did not invent the scale of what happened to you. That last part is often the most useful of the three, and it is exactly the one missing when nothing comes.

Hence a more accurate formulation: an apology shortens the road, it does not open it. In its absence, what is left to do is to grant yourself the validation the other person withholds. It takes longer. It is not out of reach, and a six-step protocol for the general case (in French) already exists.

People think you have to understand why they did it

The instruction to understand is everywhere, and it starts from an accurate observation: empathy towards the offender makes forgiveness easier. The mistake is turning that into a compulsory step, because this is where a lot of people stay stuck for years.

Looking for the reason behind an act you did not commit yourself is an exercise with no stopping rule. You can reconstruct the person’s childhood, their circumstances, their own injuries, and never reach the moment where the explanation makes the act acceptable. That moment does not exist. Understanding and excusing are not the same thing, and only the second is being asked of you by this piece of received wisdom.

You can release resentment whose cause you never worked out. The useful question is not “why did they do that”, which you will never have access to, but “what am I feeding by going back to it every day”. That is the subject of what keeps a grudge alive in the body, and that one can be observed.

Common misconception: you forgive for your own sake

The sentence is true, and it has turned into pressure. Repeated to someone who cannot manage it, it adds a fault to the injury: not only were you wronged, you are also going about recovering from it badly.

The observation has to be separated from the order. The observation holds: forgiveness works as an emotion-focused coping strategy, and it is associated with a drop in the physiological load that resentment keeps up (Worthington and Scherer, 2004). The order produces nothing. Deciding you ought to feel better does not bring anger down a single notch.

And anger is not the opponent. It signals that something that mattered was damaged, and it sometimes has a precise job: setting a limit, ending a contact, asking for repair. Sometimes refusing something without justifying yourself is the step that has to come before forgiveness, not the one that replaces it.

What brings the charge down when no apology is coming

The meta-analysis of forgiveness programmes gives one usable result: it is the interventions that ask for repeated practice time, rather than those working on the decision alone, that move the measures (Wade and colleagues, 2014). Duration therefore counts for more than the firmness of a resolution made on a Sunday night.

Four things hold up from one session to the next.

  • Name the offence in the present, once, without replaying it. A detailed retelling keeps the charge up; one short sentence makes it manageable.
  • Notice where it sits in the body for a few breaths, without trying to move it. The jaw, the shoulders or the upper belly are places to look first.
  • Come back briefly and often rather than at length once. A few minutes, several times a week, add up: what counts is the cumulative time, not the length of any one session.
  • Let the sentence of forgiveness come last, or not at all. It is not the target: it is a possible effect of the charge dropping, and aiming at it directly puts the other person back at the centre.

None of that depends on the person involved. That is the whole point of the sequence. If you have already forgiven and the pain stayed, it is usually because a decision was taken without this practice time behind it.

Received wisdom says waiting for an apology keeps you a victim

That one is false, and it is harsh. Waiting for acknowledgement is not a character flaw: it is a predictable response to a real asymmetry. Someone did something, nobody acknowledged it, and you are being told the problem is your waiting.

The distinction that matters is not between waiting and not waiting. It is between waiting that lets life carry on and waiting that puts it on hold. Hoping the sentence arrives one day, while picking your activities, your relationships and your sleep back up, damages nothing at all. Making your peace of mind conditional on that sentence, by contrast, hands the timetable of your recovery to the person who hurt you.

You can release the charge and go on thinking an apology was owed to you. Both positions hold together. It is in fact the most honest one when the situation is not going to change: the debt stays on the books, and you stop presenting it every morning to someone who will not pay it.

When forgiveness is not the thing to aim at

There are situations where forgiveness is the wrong target, and one of them is documented. Among newlywed couples followed over time, a general tendency to forgive predicted psychological and physical aggression continuing rather than decreasing (McNulty, 2011). When the harm is still going on, forgiving can remove the signal that would have stopped the behaviour.

The practical rule that follows fits in one line. If something still needs stopping, you stop it before working on forgiveness. Protection first, release second: forgiveness is an operation for afterwards, not a tool for managing the present.

Two other cases call for something other than a breathing exercise. If the memory returns as involuntary images, with a strong physical reaction every time, that is post-traumatic functioning and it is treated with a trained professional. And if waiting for an apology has filled your days for months with no practice making any difference, a psychologist will be more use than one more method. There is nothing to prove by getting there alone.

Frequently asked questions

Do you have to tell the person you have forgiven them?
No, nothing requires it. Announcing forgiveness to someone who has admitted nothing usually opens a discussion about the facts, and that discussion is the one you were trying to stop having. Saying it is only worth doing if you want the relationship back, which is a separate decision.
How do you forgive someone who thinks they did nothing wrong?
By giving up on getting them to agree about the facts, which is where this situation stalls. You can release what you carry while still believing they were in the wrong, because those are two different questions. Your account does not need their signature to be accurate.
How long does it take to forgive without an apology?
Longer than with one, and it is counted in weeks rather than days. The programmes that have been studied usually run from six to twelve hours of practice spread over several weeks. An old or repeated offence takes more, and it is normal for the charge to drop in steps rather than steadily.
Does forgiving mean you have to speak to them again?
No. Forgiveness and reconciliation are separate operations: the first is done alone, the second needs the other person to take part. You can let go of resentment and keep a permanent distance, including with a member of your own family.
What if they apologise but the apology rings false?
Treat it as no apology, because functionally that is what it is. An apology that plays down the act or hands the blame back does not carry the information that helps, which is that the harm was seen. The same approach applies, with no need to settle whether they meant it.
Can you forgive someone who has died?
Yes, and it is less unusual than it sounds, since the absence of an apology is simply permanent there. Nothing in the practice requires the other person to be present. The added difficulty, often, is that anger gets mixed in with grief, and the two are easier to handle separately.

Sources

  1. Interpersonal forgiving in close relationships: II. Theoretical elaboration and measurement — McCullough, Rachal, Sandage, Worthington, Brown, Hight, 1998
  2. The road to forgiveness: A meta-analytic synthesis of its situational and dispositional correlates — Fehr, Gelfand, Nag, 2010
  3. Forgiveness is an emotion-focused coping strategy that can reduce health risks and promote health resilience: theory, review, and hypotheses — Worthington, Scherer, 2004
  4. Efficacy of psychotherapeutic interventions to promote forgiveness: A meta-analysis — Wade, Hoyt, Kidwell, Worthington, 2014
  5. The Dark Side of Forgiveness: The Tendency to Forgive Predicts Continued Psychological and Physical Aggression — McNulty, 2011