Naming your emotions: a man sitting alone on a bench on a metro platform in the evening, his bag on his knees, looking at the wall across the tracks

Naming your emotions: what the research actually shows

10 min read

Why naming your emotions calms you, and what it leaves alone

Putting a word on an emotion does not turn its volume down: it shifts the brain's work from reaction towards language, and that shift is what makes the emotion bearable. The wording matters, because it sets what you can expect from the exercise. Nobody becomes calm because they said the word “anger”. But an anger that has been named can be discussed, placed back in its context, anticipated next time.

The reference observation dates from 2007. Lieberman and colleagues put thirty participants in an fMRI scanner and showed them emotionally charged faces. In one condition they had to pick the word matching the face's emotion. In the other, to pick a first name. Same image, same duration, one difference: the nature of the label.

When the label was an emotion word, right amygdala activity was lower, and right ventrolateral prefrontal cortex activity higher. The two moved together.

That detail is what makes the effect interesting: no participant had been told to calm down. They were asked to name, not to regulate. Torre and Lieberman reviewed the body of work in 2018 and file the phenomenon under implicit regulation, the kind that works without intention and, more awkwardly for the method's popularity, without people believing in it. Asked beforehand, participants generally expect naming to do nothing, or to make things worse.

Two caveats hold from the moment you read these papers. The size of the effect is modest, and most observations come from brief laboratory tasks on images, not from bad news landing on a Tuesday morning. The available data do not let anyone claim that a word placed on a real emotion produces the same drop in activity as a word placed on the photograph of an angry face.

What they do support is more useful than a promise of calm: naming is an act of regulation, even when it does not feel like effort.

A vague word does not do the work of a precise one

“Not great.” “I feel bad.” “Weird day.” Those sentences are technically words placed on an emotion. They open onto nothing.

Psychology has a name for the difference: emotional granularity, the fineness with which a person tells their own states apart. Two people can live through the same scene, a curt remark in a meeting, and come out of it one with “I feel bad” and the other with “I felt humiliated in front of people whose opinion counts”. The second one knows what to do with their evening. The first has only a lump.

Barrett, Gross, Christensen and Benvenuto documented this link in 2001. Their participants reported their emotions several times a day for two weeks, then the ways they handled them. Those who drew fine distinctions between their unpleasant emotions reported more regulation strategies than those who experienced them as one block. The association was specific to unpleasant emotions: on the pleasant side, it did not hold.

That result has to be read for what it is. It is an association observed on a few dozen people, not a demonstration that enriching your vocabulary mechanically enriches your ability to regulate. The direction of causality stays open.

In practice the gain does not come from the length of the list. It comes from the gap between the words. Five well-separated candidates beat forty overlapping shades:

  • Disappointed: I expected something that did not come.
  • Humiliated: someone diminished me, and there were witnesses.
  • Worried: I do not know what is coming and I am preparing for it badly.
  • Drained: I have nothing left in reserve, and it is not a question of mood.
  • Irritated: something small keeps repeating and I am not stopping it.

Each of those words points at a different move. “Bad” points at nothing. This is why an emotion that seems to arrive with no identifiable cause often lets itself be named once you look more precisely than “weird”: we covered that case in an article on tears that arrive with no obvious trigger.

Why can't I name what I am feeling?

Because it is an unevenly distributed skill, and it has nothing to do with intelligence or willpower.

In 1999, Salminen and colleagues administered the Toronto Alexithymia Scale to 1,285 people representative of the Finnish population. Alexithymia is the difficulty identifying and describing one's emotions. Result: 13% of the population, 17% in men and 10% in women.

The most useful detail in that study is not the percentage. It is the shape of the distribution: it was normal in both sexes, which led the authors to conclude it is a personality dimension rather than a category. In other words, there are not people who can and people who cannot. There is a continuum, and everyone sits somewhere on it.

Second detail, counter-intuitive: men scored higher on difficulty describing feelings and on externally oriented thinking, but no gender difference appeared on difficulty identifying feelings. The documented gap is about putting things into words, not about perceiving them.

These figures come from one country and one instrument, and the authors themselves called for comparative studies elsewhere. They do not say how many people are concerned in Britain or the United States today. They say that roughly one person in eight would recognise themselves in “I cannot put a word on this”, and that the sentence is therefore not a confession of failure.

One point deserves to be stated plainly: nothing above supports a self-diagnosis. A lasting difficulty identifying what you feel, especially if it gets in the way of daily life or relationships, is worth raising with a professional, who has more than a blog article to assess it with.

The RAIN method: naming is only the first of four steps

In mindfulness practice, the act of naming carries a letter. RAIN names a four-part sequence: recognise the emotion, allow it as it is, investigate it in the body, then nurture with kindness.

Naming is the R. A quarter of the protocol.

That proportion says something important about the limit of the exercise. A word placed and then dropped leaves the emotion exactly where it was: identified, still here. The three following steps exist because recognition alone does not do the work. We covered the four steps of RAIN and how they chain together (in French) in a separate article, and the gesture of allowing what is here without trying to correct it (in French) in another.

What is worth keeping here is the order. You cannot allow an emotion you have not identified, and you cannot investigate an undifferentiated lump. The R is not the most useful part of the sequence, but it is the one without which the others have no grip.

When the word will not come, start with the body

“What am I feeling?” is the wrong question when nothing comes. It asks for a vocabulary answer from someone who does not have one yet. The usable question is more mundane: where is it being felt?

A woman standing at her kitchen sink early in the morning, tap running, looking out of the window above the basin
When no word comes, the useful question is not “what am I feeling” but “where am I feeling it”: the throat, the chest, the stomach and the jaw answer before the vocabulary does.

Four areas answer almost always before the vocabulary does. The throat, when it tightens. The chest, when it turns heavy or narrow. The stomach, when it knots. The jaw, when it locks without anyone deciding to. None of those sensations is an emotion, but each is usable data.

Then two questions are enough to frame it, and they are binary on purpose:

  • Is this pleasant or unpleasant?
  • Is this activated or flat?

The answers sketch four territories. Unpleasant and activated: the anger, anxiety and irritation family. Unpleasant and flat: sadness, discouragement, weariness. Pleasant and activated: enthusiasm, excitement, cheerful impatience. Pleasant and flat: calm, relief, quiet satisfaction.

The word is then looked for inside a territory rather than across the whole language. That is a much shorter search.

Last step, the easiest to skip: checking that the word you found lands. Many people describe a physical difference between an approximate word and the right one: a small release, sometimes a sigh, often a sentence that follows on its own (“oh right, it's because…”). None of the studies cited here measures that marker, which stays a felt signal rather than a criterion. When nothing moves, it usually means going one notch further: “annoyed” frequently hides “I felt treated as if I did not count”.

If no word comes at all after a minute, leave it. Note the sensation and stop there. An unnamed emotion is not a failed day, and pushing tends to add irritation to the picture.

When naming does not work, and can even get in the way

Here is the part the pages on this subject leave out, which is a shame, because it is what makes the method usable.

In 2021, Nook, Satpute and Ochsner tested the hypothesis that seems obvious: if naming regulates, then naming before regulating should help. So they had participants name the emotion just before asking them to reappraise it, and, in another series, to accept it mindfully. Both strategies worked less well when they were preceded by naming.

Their proposed explanation: the word crystallises the state. It makes it sharp, therefore harder to move. What you gain in clarity you lose in flexibility.

That result does not contradict Lieberman. It draws a border. Naming helps when the goal is to sit through the emotion, to let it be here without letting it decide everything. It becomes counterproductive when the goal is to reinterpret the situation that produced it, because it locks the reading in before the rereading.

Kircanski, Lieberman and Craske (2012) show the same split from the other end, and the study is worth citing precisely. Participants who feared spiders were exposed to a live spider, then tested again a week later with a different spider in another setting. Those who had voiced their fear during the exposure showed a lower skin conductance response than the three other groups. On the fear they reported themselves, however, the groups did not differ. The body had reacted less without the reported feeling following, which is a narrower result than “it works better”. Naming while you face something: measurable. Naming instead of facing it: beside the point.

Two other cases where the exercise is the wrong tool. When the emotion is too intense for thinking to follow, you have to come down physically first and the word will arrive afterwards: that is the situation we describe in the article on what is left to do when everything overflows at once (in French). And when naming turns into a monitoring habit, with every sensation labelled continuously, the exercise flips into rumination with a better vocabulary.

Practising without spending your day on it

Two moments a day, a minute each, are enough to move something. More does not improve it, and eventually turns the exercise into an inventory.

The two most productive moments are the evening, because the day has left material, and right after something went wrong, because the emotion is still legible. The rest of the time the state is often too flat to deserve a word.

What changes, with use, rarely shows up before two or three weeks, and it is not what people expect. The emotion does not shrink much. But the delay between the moment it arrives and the moment you know what it is gets shorter, and that delay is what decides most of the reactions people regret. A gesture of kindness at that exact point changes what follows too, and it fits in a few sentences: we described it in a piece on Kristin Neff's self-compassion break.

Two things this exercise does not do, to close. It does not replace support when difficulty identifying what you feel gets in the way of daily life for a long stretch. And it does not make emotions pleasant: it makes them legible, which is a different thing, and often enough.

Frequently asked questions

Why does naming your emotions help?
Because the word changes what you do with the emotion, not how strong it is. Lieberman and colleagues (2007) observed in imaging that choosing a word for an emotion comes with lower right amygdala activity and higher activity in the right ventrolateral prefrontal cortex. Torre and Lieberman (2018) read this as implicit regulation: it works without any intention to calm down, and its size stays modest.
How long does it take to name an emotion?
A minute is usually enough, and it is better spent hunting for the exact word than analysing the situation for ten minutes. Notice where it sits in the body first, place it as pleasant or unpleasant and as activated or flat, then look for a word more precise than “bad” or “off”. If nothing comes within sixty seconds, note the sensation and leave the word for later.
What do you do when you cannot name what you feel?
Start with the body rather than the vocabulary. A tight throat, a heavy chest, a knotted stomach or a locked jaw are usable information even without a word for the emotion. The difficulty is common: Salminen and colleagues (1999) measured 13% alexithymia across 1,285 people in Finland, normally distributed in the population, which makes it a personality dimension rather than a disorder.
Should you write emotions down or say them out loud?
Both carry, and the choice depends on the moment. Writing gives you time to find the right word, which suits a confused emotion. Saying it out loud is faster, which helps once it is already here: Kircanski, Lieberman and Craske (2012) observed that voicing fear during exposure to a spider came with a lower skin conductance response a week later, facing a different spider, than distraction or reinterpretation. On the fear participants reported themselves, the groups did not differ.
Can naming your emotions make things worse?
In one specific case, yes. Nook, Satpute and Ochsner (2021) observed that naming an emotion right before trying to reappraise it, or to accept it mindfully, hindered both strategies rather than helping them. Their hypothesis is that the word freezes the state exactly when you wanted it to move. Naming is for sitting through an emotion, not for setting up its reinterpretation.
Do you need a large emotional vocabulary for this to work?
No, around fifteen clearly distinct words are generally enough. What matters is not the length of the list but the distance between the words: “disappointed”, “humiliated” and “worried” point at different situations and call for different moves, where “bad” covers all of them. A hundred-entry emotion wheel is often one more obstacle when you are starting out.

Sources

  1. Putting Feelings Into Words: Affect Labeling Disrupts Amygdala Activity in Response to Affective Stimuli — Lieberman et al., 2007
  2. Putting Feelings Into Words: Affect Labeling as Implicit Emotion Regulation — Torre & Lieberman, 2018
  3. Knowing what you're feeling and knowing what to do about it: Mapping the relation between emotion differentiation and emotion regulation — Barrett, Gross, Christensen & Benvenuto, 2001
  4. Prevalence of alexithymia and its association with sociodemographic variables in the general population of Finland — Salminen et al., 1999
  5. Feelings Into Words: Contributions of Language to Exposure Therapy — Kircanski, Lieberman & Craske, 2012
  6. Emotion Naming Impedes Both Cognitive Reappraisal and Mindful Acceptance Strategies of Emotion Regulation — Nook, Satpute & Ochsner, 2021